Happy Creek Farm: A lost Furness but a Lasting Legacy

"Happy Creek Farm"

The development and shaping of Philadelphia and the surrounding area was largely driven by the incredible industrial expansion of the city in the 19^th and early 20^th centuries.  This was a period of great commercial success that generated wealth for the companies and their owners of that time.  Philadelphia was a great manufacturing center, producing everything from Baldwin locomotives to Stetson hats.  Factories were ubiquitous in the city, and the mansions and estates of those who grew rich during this period were found within and outside the city.  Today, the industrial landscape of the city is greatly changed.  Many of the old factories are gone, replaced by parking lots, vacant tracts or other utilitarian construction.  Other factories still stand as abandoned and decaying relics of a long ago past.  The great estates of the city’s industrial giants that once dominated the Main Line and other areas around the city have also continued to largely fade from the landscape, replaced by shopping centers or housing developments that retain none of the charm and character of their great predecessors.   

One of the most important architects of Philadelphia’s Gilded Age was Frank Furness (1839-1912), who designed many beautiful and historic buildings in and around his hometown city. 

"Frank Furness"

Furness, who served in the Grand Army of the Republic during the Civil War and won the Congressional Medal of Honor, designed buildings for the Pennsylvania Railroad, the University of Pennsylvania and other institutions and companies, as well as homes for many of the areas elite families.  Sadly, many of Furness’ buildings and homes are now gone, having fallen victim to changing tastes and shifts in wealth over the years.  One of the great Furness homes stood on the estate at Happy Creek Farm in Newtown Township, Delaware County.

The relationship between Furness and Penn started with Charles Custis Harrison (b. 1844) who served as Provost there from 1894 to 1910.  Harrison has long ancestral roots in this area.  His family had established successful businesses in Pennsylvania dating back into the 18^th century.  He was a successful owner of the Franklin Sugar Refining Company, which he sold before becoming Provost at Penn.  In the early, 1890’s Harrison engaged Furness to design a country home for him and his family in Newtown Township, which he named Happy Creek Farm.  This estate was located on present day Darby-Paoli Rd where it intersects with Valley Forge Rd near Old St. David’s Church in Radnor Township. 

Harrison and his wife, Ellen Waln Harrison (b. 1846) and their six children spent a great deal of time at their country home.  The family also had a city residence on Locust St near Rittenhouse Square.  In addition to the Furness House, Harrison’s son Harry also built a home on the grounds of the estate in 1913.  But as the family aged and moved on, interest in maintaining Happy Creek Farm seemed to wane.  Followed by the death of Ellen Harrison in 1922 and Charles Harrison in 1929, their mansion went largely unoccupied and joined the growing list of lost Furness homes when it was demolished in 1937.  Eventually, Harry Harrison moved from their mansion at Happy Creek Farm to New Jersey and this house sat empty until it was demolished in 1968, shortly after his death.

Fortunately, all was not lost at Happy Creek Farm.  There was a stone house on the grounds that dated back to 1776, predating other construction on the estate by more than 100 years.  This structure was extended at least twice over its history, and was the home of Harry Harrison’s son, Roberts (now deceased).  This house survives today as a private residence.  The larger Harrison land holdings also

"Rock Rose Estate"

included the Paper Mill House (built in 1828), which stands across St Davids Rd from the stone house.  Roberts Harrison donated this historical building to Newtown Township and it was eventually restored and now serves a museum.  There are also stone barn structures that date back to the time of Happy Creek Farm that survive today as part of a private residence.  Nearby in Radnor, Rock Rose, the estate mansion of Edward Rowland and his wife Esther Harrison Rowland (daughter of Charles and Ellen Harrison) was built in1912 to serve as their home along with their two daughters.  Tragically, Edward Rowland died just after the home was built and in 1916 his wife decided to lease the home to long time tenant Lucile Carter, a survivor of the Titanic disaster.  Sadly, Esther Harrison Rowland died in 1919, leaving two young daughters without parents.  Rock Rose still exists today as a private residence.

"Dorothy Lieb Harrison"

Perhaps even more impressive than the historic architectural legacy that remains from the Harrison family is the surviving legacy of Charles and Ellen’s youngest child, Dorothy.  Dorothy Lieb Harrison was born May 30, 1886 in Philadelphia.  She attended the Agnes Irwin School for Girls in Radnor, and later attended school in England. In 1906, she married Walter A. Wood at Old St David’s Church, just across the road from the entry to Happy Creek Farm.  She lived with her husband and two children in upstate New York where they developed breeding programs for cattle.  Tragically, her husband died of typhoid fever in 1915.  At the time, her sons were only 8 and 1 years of age.  Dorothy would eventually marry again, in 1923, to a younger polo player name George Eustis.  After their marriage, they lived in Switzerland and began breeding German Shepherds and training them to serve as police dogs. 

In 1927, Dorothy wrote an article that was published in the Saturday Evening Post that told the story of her of her time in Germany at a school that trained dogs to assist soldiers who had been blinded during the first World War.  At the time, this was a very novel and innovative idea, and there was a massive response to her article back in America.  Eventually, Dorothy received a particularly passionate and moving letter from a young blind man in Tennessee named Morris Frank.   Apparently this letter served in the inspiration to establish The Seeing Eye, an institute for the training of dogs to assist in the lives of the blind.  After divorcing her second husband, she launched this effort in New Jersey, where the organization still exists today, having placed more than 16,000 dogs with those in need over the course of its history.  Dorothy Harrison Eustis remained active in the organization up to the time of her death in 1946.

Dorothy, Morris Frank and his seeing eye dog.

Today, Happy Creek Farm is no more, lost to history.  The original stone entry to the Harrison estate still stands, serving as an entry to a housing development unfortunately named “Harrison,” which is populated with several dozen very large homes with repetitive, soulless designs.  The Seeing Eye continues its work to partner trained dogs with the visually impaired, true to its original purpose of enhancing the lives of the visually disabled.  Dorothy Harrison was born into a life of wealth and privilege, which she took as an opportunity to improve the lives of others.  Today, Seeing Eye dogs are known the world over and the concept of guide dogs and other assistance pets has gained global recognition.  Most of her money went into The Seeing Eye, and thanks to careful management the organization has been financially sound since its founding.  However, the story of Dorothy Harrison and her contributions to the world are largely unknown, lost to the world along with the memory of her childhood home at Happy Creek Farm.

Information for this article was obtained from The Newtown Township Historical Society, The Radnor Historical Society, The Seeing Eye, The Saturday Evening Post, Wikipedia, and other internet sources.

The Davis Family - Local Unsung Heroes

The Davis Family - Local Unsung Heroes

If you were to walk or drive through the intersection of Conestoga Rd. and West Wayne Ave. in Radnor, it would be impossible to get any sense of the historical importance of this site. Today, on the southeast corner of the intersection, there is a small strip of commercial businesses that give no hint of what once stood on this corner. Buried behind the buildings of today on a tiny spot of land wedged between other commercial buildings and a condominium community, there is a very small graveyard that is surrounded by a black cyclone fence. On the unlocked gate to the graveyard is an unassuming plaque that reads “First Baptist Church Cemetery.” Hundreds of pedestrians and cars pass this most innocuous site every day without a trace of attention. Sadly, this graveyard and the church that once stood on that corner, are as historically significant as they are ignored.

The history of the Radnor Baptist Church begins in 1841, when more than 70 members of the Baptist Church in the Great Valley resigned from that community and broke off to form a new congregation in Radnor. The Baptist Church in the Great Valley predates the Radnor Baptist Church by 130 years, and still exists today as an active congregation that uses the stone church built for by its community in 1805. By the late 1830’s the Great Valley church had become renowned for its strong anti-slavery position, which was championed at the time by then pastor Reverend Leonard Fletcher. Reverend Fletcher’s efforts in the anti-slavery movement were well known among his fellow abolitionists and included support for the Wilberforce Society. This organization is named after William Wilberforce, who led the effort to abolish slavery in England in the early 19 th century. During Reverend Fletcher’s time, local members of the Wilberforce Society were invited to use the Great Valley Baptist Church for their meetings. However, many members of the church did not share Reverend Fletcher’s same commitment to abolition, and in 1840 he was dismissed from his position. For many of the members of the church, this was an unacceptable situation and conflicted with their deep commitment against slavery. Undeterred by this action, 79 members chose to preserve the practice of their faith and their commitment to abolition by leaving the Great Valley church, and established a new community in Radnor.

The early days for the Radnor Baptist Church were modest, and were largely made possible by William Siter and his wife Emily (Worthington), who gifted land in 1843 to the new congregation. This land was located just south of the Conestoga trail in what was then referred to as Carr’s Corner in Radnor Township. This is where current day Conestoga Road crosses West Wayne Avenue in Wayne, PA. With this gift came a structure, then known as the Music Fund Hall, which was used for services and other church business, eliminating the need to meet in the homes of members. There was also a schoolhouse on the land (Carr’s Corner Schoolhouse) that was also used by the community.

The generous role of William Siter in the early days of the Radnor Baptist Church is somewhat surprising. Despite the devout commitment of his wife to her faith, William Siter was part of a “band of nonbelievers” and he had built the Music Fund Hall on this land originally to serve as a meeting place for this group. It is not clear what went on in the Music Fund Hall, but church records from the time describe great concern over the potential negative impact of this group and their doings on the morality of the young in the area. Fortunately, this band of non-believers failed to gain much traction in the area and dissolved. Shortly thereafter, William Siter experienced a religious conversion which legend maintains was inspired by his wife. Thus, what was once a strange lodging for a notorious group of shadowy characters whose activities and beliefs are lost to history, became the first structure for the Radnor Baptist Church.

Over time, the Radnor Baptist Church expanded and grew in significance in the community, always remaining true to its abolitionist principles. Around 1890, the congregation replaced its simple wooden structure with a majestic stone church built on the same site as the Music Fund Hall. However, only a few years after the erection of the new building, some members of the congregation began to push for a relocation of the church to the center of Wayne. This group argued that the more central location in town would be beneficial to the community. A lot on Lancaster Ave next to the Wayne Title and Trust Company (still present in Wayne) was available and it was proposed for acquisition by members of the Radnor Baptist Church. Although this motion was rejected, supporters of the move were undeterred and went forward with their idea for establishing this more centrally located church. Ironically, the Central Baptist Church was established in 1896 when
many members split from the Radnor Baptist Church in an action reminiscent of the
birth of their parent church.

This split in the congregation was the beginning of the end of the Radnor Baptist Church.

Membership in the congregation continued to dwindle over the next 30 years and by 1929, the small number of remaining members concluded they lacked the resources to continue with services. Sadly, the Radnor Baptist Church had reached its end. The beautiful stone church remained unused for another 22 years until the property was bought by Louis Fillipone. The church was demolished to make way for the erection of a store, ending the 110 year history of a church that was born out of opposition to the injustice and atrocities of slavery.

The relatively short life of the Radnor Baptist Church may seem inconsequential to local history. However, the significance of this church and its community of members is revealed by a closer look at all that remains from this institution- the graveyard on West Wayne Ave. There are less than 500 people known to be interred in the Radnor Baptist Church Cemetery, and most of those were buried prior to 1930. What is most significant upon review of available records is the large number of military veterans who have been laid to rest here, including more than 20 veterans of the Grand Army of the Republic who fought for the Union during the Civil War. Perhaps more than any other record of church history, the tombstones in the graveyard for those who served in this war stand as monuments to the principles of this small and short-lived community. And none of those monuments represents a greater sacrifice to those principles than that of Mary and Stephen Davis.

Mary Smith Davis was born circa 1814, almost two years before her husband Stephen Davis, in Pennsylvania. Not long after their marriage, their family started to expand rapidly. Between 1839 and 1854, Mary and Stephen had nine children, six boys and three girls. Census records show that the Davis family children were all born when the family was living in Radnor, PA. Stephen Davis worked as a miller in Radnor while Mary tended to their growing family. The Davis’ were also members of the Radnor Baptist Church from its earliest days, and as such were no doubt strong supporters of the abolition of slavery. The clearest evidence of this is the fact that four of the Davis sons enlisted in the Grand Army of the Republic to fight for the Union. In 1861, Thomas, Stephen and Henry Davis traveled to Norristown and enlisted in the 51st Pennsylvania Regiment. Their younger brother George enlisted in the 18 th Pennsylvania Cavalry in 1864, when he was just 16 years old. This was after he had fulfilled a shorter enlistment in the 47 th Pennsylvania Infantry.

The Davis Brothers saw the war at its worst, having fought bravely in some of its most viscous battles and campaigns. And by the war’s end, the Davis family would have suffered through terrible loss. Corporal Thomas Davis was the first to fall. He was killed on September 17, 1862 during the battle at Antietam in Maryland. He was shot during the company’s attempt to take Burnside’s Bridge. He fell that day with many of his comrades in Company I, in what was one of the bloodiest battles of the war, second only to Gettysburg in casualties. It had been less than one year since he enlisted, and he had not yet reached his 22 nd birthday.

Sargent Thomas Davis was killed two years later, on June 17, 1864, early in the siege at Petersburg, Virginia. This campaign went on for nine months, and ended just a month prior to the peace at Appomattox. Sadly, this was after more than 70,000 young men and boys were killed or wounded during the campaign. Thomas was just over 22 years of age, and had been a soldier for almost three years. He was at Antietam when he lost his younger brother.

George Davis was shot while serving with the cavalry on September 28, 1864 near Rock Fish Gap, Virginia. Fortunately, George survived his wound and was mustered out of service at the war’s end. He married, raised children and lived the rest of his life in the area until he died in Malvern, PA in 1916. Henry Davis survived the war as well. Thomas and Stephen Davis were originally buried at the battlefields where they fell, but after the war, the Government paid to have their remains returned to their families. The brothers were reburied in the Radnor Baptist Church graveyard in what became the Davis family plot. Stephen and Mary Davis lived their rest of their lives in the area. Stephen died in 1887, and his wife Mary lived another 6 years. Aside from the loss of their two sons in the war, they lost their youngest daughter in 1877.

On Memorial Day, 2016, Lost History Detectives brought its investigation of the Radnor Baptist Church history to the old graveyard. Gone was the once majestic stone church on the corner of West Wayne Avenue and Conestoga Road. It has been replaced by a medical supplies company and a dry cleaners. The Central Baptist Church, which was born out of a split from the Radnor Baptist Church, still functions at its original site in Wayne. True to their social justice roots, this church remains active in the promotion of civil and human rights. The Baptist Church in Great Valley, from which the Radnor Baptist Church came into being, also still functions in a serene setting reminiscent of its earliest days 300 years ago. Funding to maintain the Radnor Baptist Church cemetery was supposed to be assured from the sale of the land once occupied by the church. Sadly, those funds were exhausted and the churchyard became neglected, overgrown with weeds and littered with debris. Recently, the cemetery came under the care of local groups and the township and is now being properly maintained. But, the quiet peace and rolling fields that once surrounded the graves are gone. The Davis family monument is still there, as are many of the other monuments from the earliest days of the church and include those of many Civil War Veterans. But with each passing year, the Davis monument grows more difficult to read, weathered flat by time. Each day, cars and pedestrians pass the tiny churchyard, unaware of its history or the stories of those who lived in that community so long ago. Equally forgotten is the long owed debt by those of today to the ordinary people of that past time, like Mary Davis and her family. But perhaps even more so, to the brothers, Thomas and Stephen. If you find yourself in the area, take a moment to visit the Radnor Baptist Church Cemetery on West Wayne Avenue as a sign of your respect and gratitude.


Information for this account was obtained from resources at the Radnor Historical Society; “The History of Pennsylvania Volunteers, 1861-1865” by S.P. Bates;Findagrave.com; www.bcgv.org; www.cbcwayne.org; and other internet sources.

Woodburne Mansion, Delaware County PA

Woodburne Mansion 1910

Woodburne Mansion 2015

On Springfield Road nestled in the trees behind Little Flower Manor sits a massively beautiful abandoned mansion. I stumbled across the house by accident on a summer night’s stroll, and when it came into view I could hardly believe what I saw. I decided to investigate and discovered the estate was called Woodburne and was owned by Edgar T. Scott. Woodburne was designed by the famous Philadelphia architect Horace Trumbauer who is known for commissions such as the Philadelphia Museum of Art and the Androssan estate in Wayne, PA. Edgar T. Scott is the son of Thomas A. Scott, who served as the President of the Pennsylvania Railroad and even more importantly, he was appointed as the Assistant Secretary of War in 1861 by President Abraham Lincoln. Thomas’s time in the war department came and went before Edgar was born in 1872. Most of the articles I’ve read during my research either stated Woodburne mansion was owned by Thomas Scott or that his son Edgar Scott was the one who worked to the Pennsylvania Railroad, both of which are untrue. Ancestry.com provides wonderful resources such as the Census report that shows Thomas Scott worked for the Railroad, lived in Philadelphia and died before Woodburne was built. The Philadelphia Historical Society holds the building plans for the mansion started in the 1900’s, more than ten years after Thomas died. 

Edgar Scott memorial

When the Trumbauer plans were completed between 1906 and 1907, Edgar Scott moved into the Woodburne Estate with his wife Mary and two sons, Edgar Jr. and Warwick. By 1910 the mansion was bursting at the seams with a growing family including two new daughters and fifteen servants. In 1917 Edgar Scott Sr. traveled to France and was assigned to General Headquarters A.E.F. and served as the assistant corps inspector at the front. In September 1918 he was promoted to major Inspector General’s department. He died October 20^th in Chaumont, France.  Edgar Scott Sr. was buried in France but there is a memorial marker in Woodlands Cemetery Philadelphia.

The Scott family continued their life at the Woodburne estate for many years. Edgar Jr. moved out and married Helen Hope Montgomery, the

Helen Hope Montgomery Scott and Edgar Scott Jr.

daughter of Robert Montgomery who owned the Androssan estate on the main line. Helen Hope Montgomery according to numerous sources inspired Katharine Hepburn’s role in the movie, “The Philadelphia Story.” Edgar and Helen moved to Wayne PA and lived in a mansion across the street from Androssan. Their son Robert Montgomery Scott eventually moved into the Androssan estate and it is now occupied by his son Robert Jr. Unfortunately this estate is a threatened piece of local history as its land was sold to developers. On a lighter note, it is a terrific coincidence that the home Edgar Jr. grew up in was designed by the same famous architect as his wife’s family home.

Mrs. Mary Scott, wife of Edgar Sr., stayed in Woodburne with her daughter Susan until the mid-1930’s. By 1935 they lived together in a home in Villanova accompanied by a few servants. The

1909 Atlas shows Edgar Scott estate stretched across 100 acres

Woodburne estate was sold to The Sisters of the Divine Redeemer and set up as an orphanage for young girls. In a 1956 Chester Times article about the orphanage, the reporter Dick Widdoes describes the house in great detail. “…taken into a huge parlor where draperies hang from the ceiling to floor windows. Comfortable furniture is tastefully arranged….The halls are waxed to perfection and polished. The large marble stairway sparkles.” By 1958 it was transformed into a home for the elderly. In the 70’s they built what is now Little Flower Manor directly in front of the mansion and by the early 2000’s the mansion was abandoned.

On my walks I would stare up into the grand windows and imagine what life would have been like to live there. One day I noticed the chain linked fence was unlocked, and the front door to the mansion was open. The DO NOT ENTER and TRESSPASSERS WILL BE PROSECUTED signs

Details show severe plant overgrowth and boarded windows.

were enough to keep me from going in. But standing out front of the door you could smell the rot and decay that has taken over the grand halls. A few months later I revisited and the door has been sealed and the gate adorned with a new padlock.

Is there a silver lining? In a Delco Times article dated November 5, 2014, it discusses a possible purchase of the estate and mansion. Former state representative Nick Micozzie helped acquire a $224,000 grant from the commonwealth of Pennsylvania’s Financing Authority’s Greenways, Trails and Recreation Program. The article states, “Micozzie said he would like to see the mansion preserved when the nuns’ property is hopefully purchased by Natural Lands Trust Inc. and turned over to Delaware County.” He envisioned the property to be “Rose Tree Park East”.

It is a wonderful thought that the estate could be turned into a much needed open space for Delaware County east. I hope the people in charge are doing their best to preserve such a fantastic piece of our history. I would think the purchase and restoration of the property would cost millions but Delaware

County is full of proud and generous people who I am sure would be willing to donate to the purchase and conservation of the house to be used for community use. Action needs to be taken immediately on this beautiful mansion before it is too late and we see a wrecking ball crashing into our local gem. I’ve tried to contact our local government for more information without luck. If you have any information for who is responsible for the future of this estate please let us know. Maybe we can all work together.

-LHD November 2015

Resources

Acestry.com

Daily Mail Reporter, “Lavish estate once owned by glittering society queen who inspired movie The Philadelphia Story faces being carved up into half-acre plots.”Dailymail.co.uk. 6 August 2013 http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2385677/The-Philadelphia-Story-Ardrossan-Estate-Pennsylvania-inspired-movie-set-carved-up.html

Justice, Glen. “The Man To Call When A New Home Was To Be A Castle”. Philly.com, 29 January 1995. http://articles.philly.com/1995-01-29/news/25712852_1_mansion-big-house-horace-trumbauer

Mueller, A.H. Atlas of Delaware County East of Ridley Creek Volume I. Philadelphia, PA. 1909-1910.

Silva, Dan. “Gen Edgar Scott”. Findagrave.com, 7 October 2010. http://www.findagrave.com/cgi-bin/fg.cgi?page=gr&GRid=59724900&ref=acom

Sumner Mead, Frederick. “Harvard’s Military Record in the World War” Pg 849. Cambridge, MA. 1921.https://books.google.com/books?id=-kQQAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA849&lpg=PA849&dq=Inspector+General+of+the+A.E.F.+at+General+Headquarters&source=bl&ots=74HR9uwTqG&sig=NeiAMuAljCtczYSy9c6zEXoDai8&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CDAQ6AEwBGoVChMI_IrukP2ByQIVgyseCh1QBA5f#v=onepage&q=Inspector%20General%20of%20the%20A.E.F.%20at%20General%20Headquarters&f=false

Widdoes, Dick. “Children Happy at Little Flower”, Chester Times, delawarecolib.newspaperarchive.com. 31 May 1956. http://delawarecolib.newspaperarchive.com/chester-times/1956-05-31/page-48

 “Editorial: Micozzie leaves fine legacy in Little Flower land”. DelcoTimes.com, 5 November 2014. http://www.delcotimes.com/article/DC/20141105/NEWS/141109867

“Notable Visitors: Thomas A. Scott (1823 – 1881)”. Mrlincolnswhitehouse.org, 2002-2015. http://www.mrlincolnswhitehouse.org/inside.asp?ID=725&subjectID=2

“Scott, Edgar T., Residence”. Philadelphiabuildings.org, 2015 https://www.philadelphiabuildings.org/pab/app/ho_display.cfm/54913

Stein, Linda “Feminism and 'The Philadelphia Story' High society topic of Cabrini talk” Main Line Media News. 3 April 2015, Main Line Media News archives. http://www.mainlinemedianews.com/articles/2015/04/03/main_line_times/news/doc551e87b961b28971923559.txt

 

 

 

Lost History at Old Blockley & Mt. Moriah Cemetery

In 1732, the Philadelphia Almshouse opened as the first government sponsored institution for the poor in America.  Originally located west of 3^rd and south of Spruce streets, the Almshouse served as a hospital for the sick and the “insane” and provided food and shelter for the poor.  In the 1830’s, the Almshouse relocated to what was then called Blockley Township, just west of the Schuylkill River, near 34^th Street and University Avenue in present day Philadelphia.  

Photo courtesy of http://www.philadelphia-reflections.com/

Growing into a complex of buildings that served the poor as hospital, orphanage,  poorhouse and an asylum for the mentally ill, the facility became known as the “Old Blockley.”  Not surprisingly, conditions at this facility were abysmal.  Management by an organization known as the Guardians of the Poor did little to support the needs of those at Old Blockley.  Newspaper accounts from the time describe the occupants as “old, sick and decrepid.”  As a consequence of the poor upkeep and lack of concern for patients and “inmates”, tragedy struck Old Blockley on July 19, 1864 when a portion of the “Female Lunatic Asylum” collapsed early in the morning, as patients were being gathered for breakfast.  At least 18 people were killed and at least 20 others were seriously injured.  Among the dead was a six year old boy named Andrew Noble.

Andrew Noble was the youngest of 8 children born to Sarah and Thomas Noble.  Thomas supported the family working as a bookbinder, with additional support provided by Andrew’s older siblings.  Limited information is available on the Noble family, however it is known that young Andrew lived with his family at least until 1860.  However, it was apparently the case that Andrew was both 

Photo courtesy of http://dla.library.upenn.edu/

physically and mentally disabled, and eventually came to reside at the Old Blockley.  On the morning of the tragic collapse at Old Blockley, Andrew had just been fed by a nurse (a Mrs. Ackley) who laid him on his couch.  Moments later, the building collapsed and Andrew was killed as he was carried down with the building into the rubble.  The scene at the collapse was described in newspapers of the time in graphic detail.  Crews were immediately dispatched to sift through the rubble to retrieve survivors and the dead, who were transported to “the dead-house” until they could be identified.  The women housed in the collapsed building were described as “…old or middle aged, and are a strange, and for the most part, extremely repulsive looking set.”  The description of the recovery and identification of Andrew’s body was also recorded: “the body of the boy Noble was brought in and although when alive he was a very repulsive specimen of humanity, being entirely idiotic and terribly crippled, still the sight of his remains so affected his old nurse that she leaned over his body, wiped the blood from his face and wept bitterly.”

Two days after his death, little Andrew Noble was buried in Mt. Moriah Cemetery.  His mother had died the previous year, and was also buried there.  At the time, Mt. Moriah was relatively new, and 

Photo courtesy of http://www.preservationalliance.com/

was located in western Philadelphia, adjacent to Cobbs Creek.  Over time, the cemetery expanded significantly in size and grew to span across Cobbs Creek into Yeadon, in Delaware County.  Mt. Moriah is the burial site of many prominent people, and includes two military burial sections which contain the remains of veterans from as far back as the Civil Way, and include many Congressional Medal of Honor recipients. Over time, management and oversight of the cemetery declined to nonexistent levels and the site was eventually abandoned.  Most of the cemetery became overgrown with vegetation, and often served as a dumping ground for trash.  Legal and financial complications have inhibited efforts to re-establish Mt. Moriah as an independently functioning cemetery.

In the aftermath of the collapse at Old Blockley, it was determined that the tragedy was likely due to construction work at the site to install heaters.  No doubt this was compounded by the physical state of decay at the facility.  No one was ever held accountable.  In the years that followed, conditions at Old Blockley continued to decline.  In 1919, the facility was renamed Philadelphia General Hospital, and was eventually closed in 1977 with its sad reputation essentially unchanged in nearly 250 years of existence.

Today, Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia occupies the site of Old Blockley.  Here, children and their families can receive state of the art medical treatment and all necessary supports in a caring environment.  Although much of Mt. Moriah Cemetery remains overgrown and in disrepair, an organization known as Friends of Mt. Moriah is working with other volunteer groups to reclaim the grounds and restore dignity to this once magnificent place of beauty and peace.  And what of Andrew Noble, who died as a victim of terrible disregard for human dignity and wellbeing at Old Blockley, and was victimized again by a similar disregard for dignity after his death at Mt. Moriah?  In 2015, Lost History Detectives visited Mt. Moriah Cemetery in search of Andrew Noble’s burial site.  With help from Friends of Mt. Moriah, the approximate location of his grave was located in section 116 in the Yeadon side of the cemetery.  More than one hundred and fifty years after his death, this young boy who lived and died in a world unable or unwilling to grant him the dignity and compassion he deserved, was remembered.

Lost History Detectives, October 22, 2015

Note: This post was supported by information from the Philadelphia Inquirer, Wikipedia, and other internet sources.

Burn Brae

Burn Brae (Photo courtesy of  AsylumProjects.org)

About eight miles west of Philadelphia into Delaware County, on the corner of Baltimore Pike and Oak Avenue, you can find the remains of what was once a…Pizza Hut. Let’s back track a little to a time before Pizza Hut and even before the famous Bazaar. Let’s go back 150 years to that same corner and visit a lush green countryside and a grand mansion that served as an escape for the elite. Did I mention it was an asylum? This was the location for The Burn Brae Sanitarium. The countryside and clean air were sought after remedies from a congested city full of crazy. Burn Brae wasn’t your normal insane institution, Dr. Robert A. Given who founded the asylum in 1859 wanted to do things a little different.

Newspaper Advertisement (photo courtesy of
whenlifewasblackandwhite.blogspot.com)

Burn Brae was intended to house and help a wealthier class of patients. In an 1895 Burn Brae brochure found at the Delaware County Historical Society, it states “The idea of placing unfortunate ones in a public asylum is often especially distasteful to those concerned who would much prefer a private institution- as establishment not prison like; a place free from grim stone walls and confining bars and bolts, a residence without the appearance of any form of coercion, a spot beautiful, soothing, restful, a homelike abode where the inmates are as guests enjoying privacy restrained in a measure and yet with the feeling of liberty”. It also stated, “Dr. Given enjoyed the distinction of inaugurating new methods of treatment now well known to all the medical fraternity.” The brochure didn’t discuss much more information on treatment but the pictures definitely helped paint a picture of how a patient might spend their day. There were pictures of the Music Hall, Bowling Alley and residents playing lawn tennis. It also lists other activities including shuffleboard, billiards, chess, croquet, cricket, boating and skating. It reminded me of an all-inclusive vacation brochure to Sandals, minus the booze since the majority of patients were there due to a drug or alcohol problem. Life at Burn Brae seemed to be picturesque.

Long story short, in 1968 the hospital was ordered closed and according to the September 13^th edition of the Delco Daily Times, for good reasons. The article reads, “The State said the hospital doesn’t have a mental health program, refuses to apply for a nursing home license, doesn’t meet housing and dietary standards and dispenses medication without a licensed pharmacist.”

It’s interesting to think about the events that transpired at this grand estate. What were the daily regiments and treatments for patients as well as the daily life of the workers? Who were they, what brought them to this place, and what happened when they left? Our goal is to uncover the lost history behind these forgotten walls and the people who came and went.

-          -Lost History Detective 

The Eyrie

The Eyrie

If you grew up in or around the Clifton Heights area of Delaware County and are at least 50 years old, it is almost certainly the case that you remember the abandoned Victorian mansion on the northwest corner of Springfield and Oak Avenues.  The “old mansion” was across Springfield Rd. from the Russell E. Miller Real Estate office, and adjacent to the old Gibson property which later became Clifton Heights Athletic Field.  The story of “the old mansion” and the property on which it stood can be traced back well over 140 years, and is linked to some of the most storied families in the long history of the area.  Perhaps the most interesting period in the long life of the “old mansion” was from 1911 to 1939, when it served as a home, and a sanitarium for the mentally ill, known as the Eyrie. 

The Eyrie
(Photo courtesy of  WhenLifewasBlackandWhite.blogspot.com)

In 1911, Dr. Wilfred W. Hawke (B. 1872, Flemington area, NJ) and his wife Aimee (nee Pennypacker, b. 1872 in Phoenxville) bought the mansion and surrounding property to serve as both a home, and as a live-in sanitarium (which they named  The Eyrie) for a small number of patients.  At the time, the Hawke’s had two daughters, Helen (b. 1908) and Mary (b. 1910).  Dr. Hawke was the son of Admiral James A. Hawke, who served as a Civil War surgeon, and retired as a Rear Admiral and Medical Director of the U.S. Navy.  Wilfred Hawke graduate from Medico-Chirurgical College of Philadelphia (once located in Center City Philadelphia, and later merged into the U of P Medical School).  Wilfred’s specialty was neurology/psychiatry, and he held positions at the Philadelphia Alms House and Hospital (which later became Philadelphia General Hospital) and the Warren State Hospital for the Insane, which still exists today under a different name.

Literature from the time refers to The Eyrie as a sanitarium where “…observational cases are preferred, and individual treatment, nursing and diet are given.  Occupational work consists of farm and garden and general house work, carpentry, basketry and painting.”  The 1920 census lists the four members of the Hawke family, two servants, one nurse and two “borders” as residents.  In the 1930 census, one of those borders, Stanton Offenheimer from Germany, was residing at the Norristown State Hospital. 

Delaware County Daily Times May 18, 1973

By 1940, the Eyrie was no more.  By then Dr. Hawke was living in a military hospital in New York.  His wife Aimee had died in 1937 and his youngest daughter Mary died two years later in 1939.  The Hawke’s older daughter, Helen, was married in 1935, and had moved to Virginia where she lived for many years.  Dr. Hawke died in 1949 in Solano County, California, where his parents and siblings had lived for many years.  Wilfred, Aimee, and Mary Hawke are buried in the cemetery at Old St. David’s Church in Radnor, PA. The Eyrie property was eventually owned by Samuel Moyerman, a Philadelphia attorney who converted it into apartments.  The property fell into disrepair and became embroiled in lawsuits between the Moyerman estate and Clifton boro over zoning issues.  The house was abandoned and fell into disrepair.  Neighbors and officials dealt with trespassers, vandalism, fires and other problems at the “old mansion” until it was eventually demolished in 1973.  Today, all that remains of the once majestic Victorian mansion is the stone retaining wall that surrounded the property. 

Lost History Detectives, Oct 12, 2015